Last week, I discussed A Place for Butterflies. If you pair it with Butterfly or Moth? How Do You Know?, you can create a great lesson that looks at text structures and how decisions about text structure impact the research process.
After reading the books to your students, ask them to discuss this following questions:
What is the primary text structure of each book?
Do you think Melissa Stewart used the same body of research to write both books? What is your evidence?
Do you think her information came from the same sources or different ones? What is your rationale?
The primary text structure of A Place for Butterflies could be described as either Cause & Effect or Problem-Solution. But Butterfly or Moth? How Do You Know? has a strong Compare ? Contrast text structure.
Hopefully, students will realize that even though both books are about butterflies, the content of each title is quite different. For Butterfly or Moth?, My main sources included books and personal observations in the natural world. For A Place for Butterflies, I relied heavily on scientific journal articles that I found using a database and interviews with scientists.